Top 5 Most Overrated Mixed Martial Arts Stars
by Jon Kirschner on January 22, 2010

Every company wants to hitch their wagon to a fighter with “charisma”, but which five have gotten the biggest push without the pedigree or skills to back it up?

5. Michael “The Count” Bisping (18 Wins, 2 Losses)

Even though “The Count” is one of the most popular and dangerous fighters to step into the UFC octagon from the United Kingdom, his legitimacy as a top-contender and a headliner should be questioned. Bisping’s impressive striking and mind-games may have won over fans, but he has never defeated an elite fighter. His two chances to prove he was a top-contender in both the light-heavyweight division and in the middleweight division failed miserably when he lost to Rashad Evans (unanimous decision) and Dan Henderson (knockout). Aside from the occasional highlight-knockout, the only reason Michael Bisping is popular is because he is the poster-boy for the UFC in the United Kingdom.

DiggThis

4. Rich “Ace” Franklin (25 Wins, 6 Losses and 1 No Contest)

After his victory over Ken Shamrock at the TUF 1 Season Finale, his popularity increased tenfold and he went on to become the UFC Middleweight Champion. What most UFC fans didn’t realize at the time was that Shamrock’s career was winding down long before Franklin knocked him out, so even though it seemed like knocking out Shamrock was a huge feat, it wasn’t as big of a deal everyone made it out to be. His reign as UFC Middleweight Champion, while impressive, was also questionable as he was matched up against subpar opponents. As soon as Franklin stepped into the octagon with the upper echelon of fighters (Anderson Silva, Dan Henderson and Vitor Belfort) his skills, or lack thereof, were exposed.

3. Cung Le (6 Wins, 1 Loss)

After his 2008 fight of the year contender against Frank Shamrock, Cung Le skyrocketed to superstardom. As a matter of fact, because Mirco Cro Cop made the transition from PRIDE FC to the UFC many fans were saying Cung Le was the owner of the most dangerous kicks in mixed martial arts. As we saw in his last fight against Scott Smith (who is 1-4 in the UFC), it’s evident his kicks are more “flashy” than “dangerous”. Le’s offense was strong and quick, but he relied too heavily on his kicks which simply did not have the knockout power he was looking for and was not able to knockout Smith when he had several chances to do so. His performance against Scott Smith was one of the biggest letdowns for Strikeforce and opened a lot of eyes.

2. Clay Guida (25 Wins, 11 Losses)

Clay Guida has been paired against numerous contenders to BJ Penn’s Lightweight Championship, but he has never been a contender himself. Despite that, he still remains as one of the lightweight division’s most popular fighters. Dana White realized that Guida’s wild style of fighting will never truly amount to great success and that nobody will ever buy a pay-per-view just to see him, but they will tune into Spike TV to see him fight for free. This is where two stars are born at once: the victor (usually Guida’s opponent) moves onto pay-per-view to fight Penn, and Guida gains an incredible amount of popularity by pulling in fans who are new to MMA because his fights are exciting and his trademark mane. Long story short, Clay Guida is the glorified stepping stone of the lightweight division.

1. Kimbo Slice (4 Wins, 1 Loss)

Throughout his five-fight career, Kimbo Slice has already been featured in three main events, one co-main event, and starred on the tenth season of the Ultimate Fighter where he was easily the most advertised fighter in the history of the show… all because he was the star of backyard fighting videos. Elite XC made an illusion that Kimbo Slice was unbeatable, but that illusion was ruined when Seth Petruzelli knocked Kimbo Slice out in fourteen seconds. Kimbo Slice definitely has the knockout power to finish fights, but that’s all he has going for him; he is a one dimensional fighter. Whenever he is taken to the ground, he as no offense or defense. Like a fish out of water, he is not familiar with that world and he starts flopping around hoping he can get back to his feet. Sure to be at the top of everyone else’s list, Kimbo Slice deserves to be the most overrated fighter in mixed martial arts history.


Last 5 posts by Jon Kirschner

Tags: , , , , , ,

Related Mixed Martial Arts Articles

more articles »

Ariel Helwani Goes After Bob Sapp in EPIC Interview

Video: WBNG Coverage of Jon Jones' Wrecked Bentley and Slightly Wrecked Light Pole

Live Video: NSAC Commission Meeting (Nick Diaz's Punishment And Chael Sonnen's TUE Request)

Fight Announcements Galore! Catching Up With The Latest In MMA

Jon Kirschner

view profile »

Facebook comments:

  • Alex D

    Bisping’s loss to Rashad Evans was a split decision, not unanimous. Is a split decision loss to an elite fighter really “failing miserably?”

    And for Rich Franklin- in my eyes the only fighter who really “exposed” him was Anderson Silva, and Silva does that to everyone. His loss to Hendo was very close (some people scored the fight for Franklin) and in the Belfort loss he got caught very early, which doesn’t prove all that much to me.

  • Damnufine

    also Franklin beat Wanderlie, which hurt me as Silva is my all ime fav lol. Wanderlie is still dangerous even though he hasn’t been the same since his Pride concusions.

  • http://insidefights.com Jon Kirschner

    Alex D: Good catch with the decision. But to answer your question, I think attempting to make the leap from fighter to elite fighter in two different divisions and losing is a failure. He has his chance to redeem himself against Silva, and this can bump him up a lot. Id like to throw it out there that Bisping is one of my personal favorites.

  • http://composta.net/versus Coyote

    There is a lot of overated fighters on the UFC. But the most for sure is:

    Brandon “The Bad Truth” Vera

  • Rob

    I’m baffled by this list…just in shock…

    because you are in co-main or main events doesn’t mean you are over-rated. it means people will pay to see you fight.

    Franklin is a product of the previous UFC era in that no one great was in his division at the time he was champ. His only losses are to great fighters. Kimbo has never been declared as a great fighter, so i have no idea how you can say him. Bisping has taken the same road (as far as fights) that Hardy has, except that bisping lost in his contender fight whereas hardy won. If Bisping had beaten Hendo he would be ranked top 10 similar to hardy beating swick. Guida? Im just in shock…the LW division is stacked and guida is ranked i’d say top 15 in the world for LW, his only recent losses are to big named contenders, so wtf?

  • http://insidefights.com Jon Kirschner

    Rob: I’m not saying these guys are overrated fighters at all; they all are fantastic fighters in their own right. I’m saying they’re overrated stars. Of course Elite XC couldn’t have done anthing else with Kimbo but main event him, and I don’t blame him or Elite XC for doing so. But I will say that he doesn’t deserve to be where he is.

  • Pingback: Top 5 Most Overrated Mixed Martial Arts Stars - MMA News Forums

  • http://criticasweb.com Paola

    Clay Guida is more like a “stepping boulder”. If that dude could generate electricity, he would be Blanka. (…and/or if he was green)

  • jesus

    rashad evans is by far the most overrated figheter in mma

  • bazza76

    Sorry Jon.
    Can’t agree with your list, well apart from Bisping and Kimbo who should be there or there abouts.
    Franklin, Guilda and Lee are all legit fighters and earned their hype by being good fighters.
    Kimbo got his hype from back yard brawling and Bisping for being Brittish.
    But the rest, shouldn’t be on the list IMO.
    Even Bisping is a little harsh.

  • Dave

    How is Fedor NOT on this list? You want to talk about over rated. He’s Rocky in Rocky III. Being spoon fed hand picked fighters who are good if unspectacular. He is Mr. Over rated.

    Better Heavyweights: Lesnar, Mir, possibly Carwin.

    Better pound-for-pound: St. Pierre, Anderson Silva, BJ Penn.

  • Damnufine

    Dave, Fedor battered a young Nog. Fedor crushed Heath Herring and did far more damage to him than Brock. Fedor really isn’t that big and yet he fights super heavyweights and wins. Randy couldn’t handle old Nog, I doubt Mir will beat Nog a second time if Nog is healthy. FEDOR BEAT PRIME NOG! nuff said really

  • John Galt

    Uh…Cheick Kongo?!!!! HELLO?!!! Yeah, he’s built like King Kong and is a good striker but other than that he sucks. His ground game (or lack thereof) is horrible, no submission ability to speak of, and shitty take down defense. Here is my list:

    5. Matt “Cheer for Me Because I’m Deaf” Hamill

    4. Houston “Swing, Miss, and Gassed” Alexander

    3. Cung “I Only Fight Washed Up UFC Fighers” Le

    2. Kimbo “The Chest Hair Artist” Slice

    1. Cheick “The Missing Link” Kongo

  • Pingback: Top 5 Most Overrated Mixed Martial Arts Stars : SCRAPP! Fight Magazine

  • http://insidefights.com Jon Kirschner

    Kongo definitely deserves to be on this list, I just couldn’t justify putting him above Bisping (especially after how he got dominated by Mir— his value dropped down a lot after that fight).

    Thanks for the feedback, everybody!

  • Pingback: Cool Combat Sports Links: Mixed Martial Arts, Wrestling, Boxing (1-24-10) : FIGHT NEWS UNLIMITED

  • http://joetetebodybuilder joe tete

    this guy john galt got it down pat…

Blowing Up Blogs

Recent Comments

Search Pulse

Author:

Zone:

Category:

mma news
boxing news
So, with this Simple Jquery Modal Window, it can be in any shapes you want! Simple and Easy to modify : )