Top Ten MMA Fighters of the Decade
by Jon Kirschner - December 31, 2009 | Email the author

Join me as I take a look through ten years of mixed martial arts in this countdown of the top ten mixed martial artists of the 2000s.

10. Wanderlei Silva (22 Wins, 8 Losses, 1 Draw and 1 NC in the 2000s)
Wanderlei Silva was the PRIDE FC Middleweight Champion from 2001 to 2007, successfully defending his title four times in the process. That alone is a good enough reason as to why he belongs on this list, but it doesn’t stop there for “The Axe-Murderer”. Easily the craziest and most violent fighter in the sport (he has a tribal tattoo on the back of his head!), Wanderlei Silva was the king of PRIDE before Fedor arrived. Wanderlei is most known for his fights with Kazushi Sakuraba and Quinton Jackson in PRIDE FC, both of whom he dominated. The first time Silva saw defeat in the PRIDE Middleweight Division was two events prior to the folding of the company against Dan Henderson, a fight which Silva seemed to have the upper-hand. Wanderlei hopes to get back on track at UFC 110 against Michael Bisping.

9. Chuck Liddell (17 Wins, 6 Losses in the 2000s)
Chuck Liddell was one of the most controlling fighters UFC has ever seen. Chuck Liddell started off the decade with a seven-fight win streak, and continued his hot-streak into Japan when he fought in the PRIDE Middleweight Grand Prix where he lost in the semi-finals to Quinton Jackson. He returned to the UFC and went on ANOTHER seven-fight win streak, all won by knockouts, defeating Randy Couture for his UFC Light-Heavyweight Title in the process. Since then, Liddell has been on a slump with only one win in his last five fights, but he hopes to make another impactful return next year when he goes up against Tito Ortiz.

8. Randy Couture (13 Wins and 8 Losses in the 2000s)
With a total of eight losses in the 2000s, it is arguable that “The Natural” should be number eight, but you have to take several factors into consideration. Randy Couture won the UFC Heavyweight Title twice this decade and successfully defended his title four times which can easily lead one to the assumption that he was the elite heavyweight in America. His first light-heavyweight stint showed how versatile he was as he won the UFC Light Heavyweight Title twice, becoming the first five-time champion and the first man in the UFC to hold two belts of two different weight classes. The three fight series with Chuck Liddell elevated MMA to a whole new level and factor in that he is 46 years old and still going, it just goes to show that he truly is one of MMA’s top warriors of the decade.

7. Matt Hughes (30 Wins and 6 Losses in the 2000s)
Before Georges St. Pierre made his UFC debut, Matt Hughes was the welterweight powerhouse. Hughes is as strong as any other guy in his division or the one above him; the way he would pick guys up and slam them down on the mat was downright scary. He uncrowned Carlos Newton as UFC Welterweight Champion back in November of 2001 and made his mark as the most controlling UFC fighter at the time. It wasn’t until “The Prodigy” BJ Penn moved up a weight class that Hughes saw a loss, but he came back with a six fight winning streak which included an avenged victory over an outclassed BJ Penn. Since then Hughes has fallen on hard times, but a win over Matt Serra at UFC 98 has reignited the fire in his eyes.

6. Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira (28 Wins, 5 Losses, 1 Draw and 1 NC in the 2000s)
Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira, hands-down, would be the most feared fighter in the world if it wasn’t for Fedor Emelianenko. Before Fedor, Nogueira tore through his competition despite being battered and broken— his resiliency is his best quality. During his reign as PRIDE FC Heavyweight Champion, he used his astonishing mastery of brazillian jiu-jitsu to submit his opponents. While in the UFC, he defeated heavyweight-hopeful Heath Herring and then UFC Heavyweight Champion Tim Syliva to become the first fighter to hold belts in the UFC and PRIDE FC. Following a disappointing loss to Frank Mir, Nogueira returned in top-form against Randy Couture, winning by way of unanimous decision.

5. BJ Penn (15 Wins, 5 Losses and 1 Draw in the 2000s)
“The Prodigy”… Never before has a nickname been so fitting. Penn started his MMA career in the UFC by knocking out all competition set before him until he lost a UFC Lightweight Championship match to Jens Pulver by way of unanimous decision. The interesting thing about BJ Penn and his losses is that they were internal victories as well; Penn studied his losses, learned from them and returned better than ever. Though he ran into the proverbial roadblocks of Matt Hughes and Georges St. Pierre, he still won the UFC Welterweight Title and the UFC Lightweight Title become the second man in UFC history to hold two different titles in two different weight classes.

Penn is the reigning UFC Lightweight Champion and has finished every single fight in that division since he became champion. The only man who could possibly be seen as a challenge to Penn is “The Fireball Kid” Takanori Gomi, a man who BJ Penn already submitted back in 2003. Beyond the shadow of a doubt, BJ Penn is right where he should be: top lightweight fighter in the world.

4. Georges St. Pierre (19 Wins and 2 Losses in the 2000s)
The current UFC Welterweight Champion Georges “Rush” St. Pierre is the reason why many fans became loyal followers of the sport of mixed martial arts and made history when he became the first mixed martial artist to be sponsored by Gatorade and Under Armour. As incredible feats as they are for any competitor, those are not the reasons why GSP earned to be on this list. He walked into the UFC willing and ready to learn. He blasted through Karo Parisyan and Jay Hieron in impressive fashion to earn a shot for the vacant UFC Welterweight Title. He lost the bout to Matt Hughes by submission, and sought out to find the best wrestling coach he could find. He returned to the UFC and went on a five-fight winning streak, which led him to a rematch for Matt Hughes’ Welterweight Title. After winning it in dominant fashion, he lost it to Matt Serra after getting knocked out. He regained rights as Undisputed Welterweight Champion after defeating Matt Hughes for the interim-Welterweight Title and Matt Serra to unify the two belts— and he hasn’t lost since. GSP is the most complete fighter I’ve ever seen, and I doubt he will lose a fight, let alone a title, in a very long time.

3. Dan Henderson (19 Wins and 7 Losses in the 2000s)
As one of the most popular fighters to ever step into a ring or a cage, former olympian Dan Henderson earns bronze on this list. Henderson started 2000 off with two consecutive wins, leading him to debut in PRIDE Fighting Championship. While in PRIDE, Henderson won the PRIDE FC World Welterweight Title (defeated Murilo Bustamante) and PRIDE FC World Middleweight Title (defeated Wanderlei Silva) to become the first MMA fighter ever to hold two titles in two weight classes in a major MMA organization at the same time. His second UFC run was nothing to be ashamed of either as he defeated Rich Franklin and Michael Bisping. His recent signing with Strikeforce should lead to exciting middleweight and light-heavyweight bouts, but his rumored first fight may be against Strikeforce Middleweight Champion Jake Shields for the title.

2. Fedor Emelianenko (31 Wins, 1 Loss and 1 NC in the 2000s)
If one were to look at who Fedor Emelianenko has defeated while in PRIDE Fighting Championship, they would know it was essentially a “who’s who” in the UFC Heavyweight Division- both past and present. With only one loss to his name (a controversial stoppage due to a cut) Fedor tore through Mark Coleman, Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira, Andrei Arlovski, Tim Sylvia (all former UFC Heavyweight Champions), and others in PRIDE FC and Affliction to solidify his position as the top heavyweight mixed martial artist in the world. His recent knockout over top Strikeforce heavyweight Brett Rogers was the most brutal I’ve seen all year, and I can guarantee there will be more to come over the next decade for Fedor.

1. Anderson Silva (25 Wins and 4 Losses in the 2000s)
Anderson Silva is arguably the most diverse and dangerous fighter on this list. Proven that he has learned from his past losses (decision, disqualification and two submissions) Anderson Silva decimated most competition in PRIDE Fighting Championship, Cage Rage (capturing their Middleweight Title), and has gone undefeated in two of Ultimate Fighting Championship’s most-stacked divisions.

Though some can argue that Fedor’s dominance around the world should give him the number one spot, he simply is not seeking out the best competition for himself. Strikeforce should give Fedor some more exciting fights and highlight-reel knockouts, but it’s clear that his biggest challenges await him in the UFC’s Heavyweight Division. Anderson Silva, on the other hand, has cleared out the UFC Middleweight Division and ventured into the UFC’s Light-Heavyweight Division for more diverse opponents. The thing is, Anderson Silva did not fight in the light heavyweight division for the fans, nor did he do it for attention. He did it to challenge himself and to see if there was anybody in the UFC that could truly beat him. Above his record and above his highlight reel knockouts, it was his mindset that got him top bill as “Number One Mixed Martial Artist of the Decade”.

Last 5 posts by Jon Kirschner

Jon Kirschner
Related Posts
(Click on any zone, category or tag to see a list of related posts)
Zones:
Categories: MMA Columns () | Mixed Martial Arts () |
Tagged as: anderson silva (130) | Antonio Rodrigo Noguiera (6) | B.J. Penn (88) | Chuck Liddell (81) | dan henderson (40) | Fedor Emelianenko (107) | Georges St. Pierre (83) | Matt Hughes (28) | Randy Couture (129) | Top Ten Fighters of the Decade (1) | Wanderlei Silva (37) |

Facebook comments:

8 Comments

[...] read more Filed Under: Floyd Mayweather, Freddie Roach, HBO 24/7, Manny "Pacman" Pacquiao, Manny Pacquiao, Manny Pacquiao vs. Floyd Mayweather Jr., Mayweather vs. Pacquiao, Pacquiao, Pacquiao Sparring, Wild Card Gym, pacman, pacmonster, top rank promotions. [...]

I will admit right off the bat I dont know a whole lot about MMA but its just shocking to me that a guy who goes 13-8 in the 2000′s is considered one of the best in the sport. Ive just never understood how guys who get beat so often are considered great fighters. I know Couture has an amazing story and was never a real heavyweight but the greatest in a sport should be able to dominate a little more than 13-8 right. I like how you at least tried to explain yourself for the pick tho

13-8. Maybe what your missing there is that a very large portion of those wins and losses came at the hands of the best in the sport. Matt Hughes has a record a much more in depth record but many of those wins came against guys weve never heard of. Randy has never fought anything but the best in the sport and the majority of his fights have been for a title. That in itself is more impressive than most people can take credit for. Were talking only a couple fights that werent for titles. To doubt Coutures legacy or his accomplishments based on his record does not allow for you to look deeper into what truly makes him so great. Jon, I was going to take this article, and Im glad seeing your piece knowing that my picks were almost identical to yours. A fine write up on some legendary fighters. Great job bro, impressive.

Dan Handerson with 7 losses is #3? LOL!

Silva above undefeated Fedor? LOL!

This list looks like “who are my favorite fighters” rather than top 10 mma fighters.

13 wins and 8 losses?: I understand where you’re coming from. But his losses are against elite fighters (a couple of them are on this list, actually). Todd explained it perfectly in his reply.

Todd: Thanks a lot for the kind words, man.

Jerry: Addressing the matter of Dan Henderson, I can see how some may think that he deserves to be lower on this list, but I think his ability to finish fights against the fighters he’s fought justified his position at number 3. Onto the matter of Anderson and Fedor, again, I see where you’re coming from. I explained my POV already in the article, but I want to point out another reason why I put Silva on top. Anderson Silva has shown no signs of slowing down and no weaknesses in his game lately… he’s basically unbeatable… he’ll dissect anyone he fights. Fedor on the other hand, has shown (recently against Rogers) holes in his game and is beatable. His fight with Rogers wasn’t the last time he was on spaghetti legs. And as far as this being a “my favorite fighters list”, I don’t like Liddell, Henderson, Hughes or Couture one bit, yet they are on my list.

this list is good but id do some switching around myself
1.Anderson Silva
2.Fedor Emelianenko
3.Georges St.Pierre
4.BJ Penn
5.Dan Henderson
6.Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
7.Matt Hughes
8.Chuck Liddel
9.Randy Couture
10.Wanderlei Silva

i understand why you put people where you did but GSP’s dominance and BJ’s recent dominance is enough for me to put them ahead of Dan even though he is impressive and id put Chuck ahead of Couture purely based on record if Liddel would’ve retired just a bit earlier his record would’ve been close to perfect.

To place Henderson above GSP and Penn is questionable to say the least, though I guess it’s down to personal opinion.

St-Pierre has literally crushed every opponent he has faced since losing to Serra in 07. He outwrestled the veteran wrestler Huges, dominated and bloodied a lightweight champion in BJ, and hasn’t shown a weakness in any area since the aforementioned loss.

Penn has a good – but not perfect – record. But everyone he has fought since 2006 has been an elite fighter. He dominated an in-his-prime Hughes on two occassions, before injuring himself in the second battle. He dropped Sanchez in less than a minute – the only 155lb considered to really stand a chance against Penn after Florian.

And how can you forget Shogun?! The guy entered PRIDE at 22 years old, won the 2005 GP at 23, and is the only man to have solved the Machida puzzle.

For me, looking at the list from a retrospective viewpoint, it’d be:

1. Anderson Silva
2. Georges St-Pierre
3. Fedor Emilianenko
4. BJ Penn
5. Mauricio Rua
6. Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
7. Chuck Liddell
8. Randy Couture
9. Dan Henderson
10. Wanderlei Silva

Add Your Comment
Name *
E-mail *
Comment
POLLS

Pick The Winner: Frankie Edgar vs. BJ Penn II

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Categories